This Pie Takes the $10,000 Prize: America’s Best Blueberry Pie Winner Announced

FOLSOM, Calif. – As the crowning touch to National Blueberry Month, the U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council (USHBC) today announced the winners of the America’s Best Blueberry Pie Contest. USHBC received an impressive 234 blueberry pie recipes in 29 days from blueberry fans across the nation. Tieghan Gerard, the New York Times best-selling author of two cookbooks and the Half Baked Harvest blog, served as the final judge, selecting the three winners.

2021 America’s Best Blueberry Pie Contest Winners

  1. Grand PrizeGinger ‘n’ Spice Bubbling Blueberry Pie

Barbara Estabrook, Appleton, Wisconsin

  1. Second Prize: Dreamy Creamy Blueberry Slab Pie 

Renata Stanko, Lebanon, Oregon

  1. Third Prize: Honey Roasted Blueberry and Ginger Marshmallow Cream Pie  

Veronica Callaghan, Glastonbury, Connecticut

The winning recipes received prizes of $10,000, $1,500 and $1,000, respectively, and are featured on our blog here. The grand prize winner, the Ginger ‘n Spice Bubbling Blueberry Pie, by Barbara Estabrook, receives the added honor of becoming the official blueberry pie of USHBC and the blueberry industry.

“I am so grateful! I baked my very first blueberry pie when I was just 10 years old in 4-H Club (a youth development and mentoring organization). After picking all the blueberries, I still remember how proud I was to bring that pie home to my mom,” says Estabrook. “I started baking this Ginger ‘n’ Spice Bubbling Blueberry Pie for the veterans at the American Legion Camps about 8 years ago. It took 1 1/2 hours to pick the 5 cups of blueberries that went into each pie – lots of work, but all worth it!”

“You could feel the love for blueberries poured into every recipe submitted for the America’s Best Blueberry Pie Contest,” said Kasey Cronquist, president, the U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council. “Blueberries pair so well with different foods and flavors, and the top recipes incorporated creative ways to complement their sweet-tart taste. Congratulations to all the winners, especially Barbara and her Ginger ‘n’ Spice Bubbling Blueberry Pie, which delivered a definitive boost of blue.”

The America’s Best Blueberry Pie Contest judging process began with culinary pro Gwynn Galvin, who reviewed all recipe submissions and narrowed down the written recipes to the top 10. Then, Gwynn, along with Shelly Hartmann, blueberry farmer and chair of the U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council, and a pastry chef team tested the top 10 blueberry pies narrowing them to the top 5. Finally, Half Baked Harvest tested and tasted the top 5, ultimately naming the three winners.

“Life is made for enjoying pie – especially blueberry – and it was a true pleasure to taste-test these delicious, creative culinary innovations with the U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council,” said Gerard. “I know the expression is ‘easy as pie,’ but whoever coined that term wasn’t trying to decide between so many mouthwatering recipes! The Ginger ‘n’ Spice Bubbling Blueberry Pie grabbed me immediately as a twist on the traditional – I love the combination of the spices, ginger and orange marmalade mixed in with the blueberries.”

Each July, USHBC creates fresh opportunities to celebrate blueberries for National Blueberry Month. This year, on National Blueberry Day (July 8), Chef George Duran took blueberries to new heights, trying to beat the GUINNESS WORLD RECORDS® title for the tallest stack of pancakes. His Stackable Blueberry Pancakes recipe, the winning blueberry pie recipes and many more offer inspiration for blueberry fans to enjoy fresh blueberries all summer, which is peak season in North America. Whether hand-picked at local farms or grocery stores, blueberries make a simple, healthy and delicious addition to any snack or dish.

For more information about blueberries, including recipes, tips and hacks, visit


About the U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council

The U.S. Highbush Blueberry Council is an agriculture promotion group, representing blueberry growers and packers in North and South America who market their blueberries in the United States and overseas, and works to promote the growth and well-being of the entire blueberry industry. The blueberry industry is committed to providing blueberries that are grown, harvested, packed and shipped in clean, safe environments. Learn more at