America’s Oldest Cheese Shop Located in Little Italy to Close After 130 Years in Business

February 14, 2023 Jenna Bernath, AMNY

The shop is known for its lengthy menu of Italian delicacies, including fresh mozzarella, ricotta, cured meats, cannolis and sandwiches. Through the generations, this menu has not only captured the love of the community, but also caught the attention of celebrities, including Tony Danza, Leah Remini and Joey Reynolds.